Hot Penny Stocks. Below is a list of what we consider the current best penny stocks (stocks under $5). Our algorithm examines 7,955 different penny stocks from NASDAQ, AMEX, NYSE, and OTC MARKETS to find the best ones to buy based on a proprietary set of conditions. Here’s the good news: I’ve done the homework for you. Below is my list of the Top Five Penny Stocks to buy now, with an eye toward representing diverse industries. Let’s roll up our sleeves and get right to it. Our Best Penny Stocks for 2019. Below are my top five picks for penny stocks: Best Penny Stocks Under $1 Check in daily to find the best stocks under $1. premarket, aftermarket, movers, and best performance. This list is updated daily and active throughout the day.